Broadway During the Holidays: Top Picks for Group Travelers
So, you’re bringing a group to New York City for the holidays. The itinerary is packed—seeing the Rockefeller Center tree sparkle in person, wandering through the festive window displays, maybe even spotting Santa on Fifth Avenue. Between shopping sprees and hot chocolate pit stops, there’s one thing you can’t skip: a night (or two) on Broadway. After all, nothing captures the magic of the city quite like the energy of a live show—the lights, the music, the feeling that anything can happen.
When it comes to scoring tickets to the best of Broadway without a hitch, Broadway Inbound is your all-access pass to theatrical magic. Specializing in group ticket sales, they roll out the red carpet to make it easier than ever to find and secure seats for the latest and greatest spectacles lighting up Broadway. Whether you're coordinating for a crew of theatre first-timers or seasoned show enthusiasts, Broadway Inbound takes the guesswork out of planning the perfect outing—ensuring your group is seated, smiling, and ready for the curtain to rise.
Now, onto the main attraction: those must-see, show-stopping productions that have theatregoers buzzing. From high-energy musicals to heart-tugging dramas, the season’s lineup is bursting with enough spirit to illuminate Times Square. Ready to dive into a collection of performances that will have your group humming all the way back to the hotel? Let’s take a look at this year’s unmissable shows!
JOLLY HOLIDAY
If your group is craving something that captures the sparkle and joy of the season, this lineup brings all the glitter, laughter, and feel-good energy you could ask for. These are the shows that’ll have you singing, smiling, and maybe even dancing your way down Broadway once the curtain falls.
Death Becomes Her
This exuberant new musical puts a Broadway spin on the cult classic 1992 film about two beauty-obsessed rivals and the price of immortality. With dazzling costumes, a plot that's both absurd and endearing, it’s no wonder it’s captivated audiences. With a slew of killer songs that humorously winks at Broadway conventions, your group will be chuckling from curtain to encore. Get ready for a magical night of laughs and jaw-dropping performances that’ll have everyone in your crew talking!
Mamma Mia!
This crowd-pleaser is like a shot of sunshine on a snowy day. Set on a Greek isle, the story of a bride, her mother, and her three possible fathers weaves ABBA’s timeless hits through its charming journey of love and friendship. Prepare for a contagious energy that’ll have your group tapping their feet and singing along to iconic songs like "Dancing Queen" and "Take a Chance on Me." Perfect for all ages and guaranteed to leave everyone giddy with joy, Mamma Mia! is a feel-good extravaganza that embodies the essence of holiday cheer.
& Juliet
Ever wondered what would happen if Juliet ditched the tragic ending and decided to write her own story? Enter & Juliet—a playful reimagining of Shakespeare's classic tale, complete with a pop hit-filled soundtrack. This bubbly and empowering musical features hits made famous by artists such as Britney Spears, Pink, and Katy Perry, and promises lively choreography, stunning visuals, and plenty of belly laughs. Ideal for groups who love a good twist on tradition, & Juliet is a modern-day delight that's as entertaining as it is uplifting.
Photo courtesy of Matthew Murphy.
SOMETHING TRADITIONAL
Venture off Broadway for two of the city's perennial holiday favorites. These timeless productions wrap you in classic elegance—the kind of performances that define the holiday season in the city. Think twinkling lights, soaring music, and traditions that never go out of style.
New York City Ballet's George Balanchine's The Nutcracker
Step into a world where dreams take flight with New York City Ballet's George Balanchine's The Nutcracker, a quintessential holiday treat. As the clock strikes midnight, join a brave young girl on a magical adventure filled with battling toy soldiers, mischievous mice, and a journey to the enchanting Land of Sweets. From the lilting strains of Tchaikovsky’s timeless score to the mesmerizing whirl of ballerinas gliding through snowflakes, this cherished performance captures the imagination of audiences of all ages. It's a heartwarming spectacle that promises to sprinkle your holiday season with wonder and joy.
The Metropolitan Opera's The Magic Flute
Transport your group to a fantastical world of mythic creatures and mystical enchantments with The Metropolitan Opera's family-friendly adaptation of Mozart's The Magic Flute. Performed in an English version that retains all the soaring beauty of the original, this whimsical opera offers a visual feast with vibrant costumes and breathtaking sets. With its delightful blend of comedy, adventure, and a sprinkling of magic, it’s the perfect introduction to opera that will leave the entire group enchanted and humming the beautiful melodies long after the curtain falls. It's a tradition as legendary as it is lovely, offering a brilliant start—or end—to any festive holiday itinerary.
SOMETHING UNTRADITIONAL
If your group likes to mix things up, skip the usual and go for a show that surprises, delights, and dazzles in unexpected ways. Here “holiday magic” just means “magic.” These productions reimagine what Broadway can be—blending illusion, innovation, and jaw-dropping creativity.
Amaze
Step into the world of Jamie Allan—where magic meets technology and you become part of the illusion. This show reimagines old-school sleight-of-hand with laser lights, drones, augmented reality, and story-driven spectacle—all unfolding on a set that evokes a dreamlike attic of memories. Expect to be delighted, surprised, and maybe even to question reality a little—perfect for a group looking to catch something fun, interactive, and completely unexpected.
Photo courtesy of Matthew Murphy.
Harry Potter and the Cursed Child
This production invites you into the wizarding world like never before—the entire theatre has been transformed, and from the moment you step inside, you’re part of the magic. The story picks up where the Harry Potter book series leaves off, centering on the next generation of magic-makers: when young Albus Potter befriends the son of his famous father’s rival, it sparks an adventure that ripples through time, filled with spectacular illusions and emotional stakes. For groups drawn to an immersive atmosphere, fandom energy, and awe-inspiring visuals, this is a must-see.
There you have it—a perfectly curated lineup of Broadway and classic arts delights that will add a touch of magic to your New York City holiday adventure! Whether you're chasing the sparkle of holiday musicals, the timeless allure of classic performances, or simply a night out that promises to entertain and inspire, there's something for every taste on this list.
And remember, Broadway Inbound is your trusted partner in navigating the bustling world of NYC theatre. With their expertise in group ticket sales and access to the best seats, they take the stress out of planning, leaving you free to soak up every moment of your theatrical journey. From discovering new shows to securing those must-have tickets, Broadway Inbound makes your Broadway experience as seamless as it is unforgettable.
So go ahead, embrace the excitement, relish the stories, and let Broadway be the superstar of your holiday itinerary!
Courtesy of Broadway Inbound.
Main photo courtesy of Matthew Murphy and Evan Zimmerman.
